A trial is when both sides present their case in front of a judge (or sometimes a jury). The judge listens to the evidence and decides the outcome. Here’s what usually happens.
Before the trial begins
The judge takes care of basic matters, like scheduling and what evidence will be allowed.
Opening statements
Each side gives a short summary of what they believe the evidence will show.
Debt collector's case
The creditor goes first. They present their witnesses and documents. You have the right to ask questions (cross-examine) and object if something is unfair or not allowed.
Common objections to evidence include:
- Foundation & authentication: Documents must be shown to be genuine.
- Hearsay: Out-of-court statements are inadmissible unless an exception applies (e.g., business records).
- Assignments: Object if the creditor can’t show a complete chain of title to your account.
- Accuracy: Question interest, fees, and balance calculations.
- You can try to challenge the creditor if they try to introduce business documents that were created by a different company, because they have no way to know the numbers are correct.
Your case
After the creditor finishes, it’s your turn. You can present your own witnesses and evidence. The creditor’s lawyer can also ask your witnesses questions.
Rebuttal
If needed, each side can respond to new issues raised by the other side.
Closing arguments
Both sides explain why the judge should rule in their favor, based on the evidence shown.
Decision
The judge may give a ruling right away or take time to review and decide later.
If a jury is deciding the case, they may leave the courtroom to discuss the evidence before deciding the case.
💡 Remember: The debt collector has the burden of proof. That means it’s their job to prove you owe the debt, they own the debt, and the amount is correct.