Voluntarily surrender your car
Prefer to read about this option first? Show the option.
Overview
If you can no longer make payments, you might be able to do a voluntary surrender. This is when you proactively return the vehicle to the creditor rather than waiting for the lender to forcibly repossess it. It doesn't eliminate the debt, but it can save you quite a bit on costs and fees.
Pros
- No tow or repossession fees: You bring the car to your lender, so they don’t need to send someone to find or tow it. You may still owe other costs under your loan.
- You choose when and where: You can arrange a day and drop-off location with your lender. This gives you time to find another way to get around and remove your belongings from the car.
- You keep the car until you hand it over: You can use the car while you arrange the handoff. Ask your lender whether they’ll discuss any fees or remaining debt with you.
Cons
- You may still owe money: Your lender will usually sell the car. If the sale doesn’t cover your loan balance and allowed costs, you may have to pay the difference, or arrange for a payment plan.
- You lose the car when you hand it over: Once you give the car to your lender, you generally can’t take it back.
- Your credit may be affected: A voluntary surrender can appear on your credit report much like a repossession. It may still hurt your credit.
How do I do this?
Find out how much you owe and what the car is worth
Before you decide what to do with your car, find out two things: how much it would cost to pay off the loan and how much you could sell the car for.
Ask your lender for a payoff quote
The payoff amount may be different from the balance on your last statement. It may include interest and fees.
Call your lender and ask for a written payoff quote. Ask for:
- The total amount needed to pay off the loan and the date that amount is good through,
- How much the amount will increase each day after that date, if it does,
- A list of any fees included, and
- Where and how to send the payment.
If you do not pay by the date on the quote, ask for a new one.
Find out what the car is worth
Look up your car in a free online value guide, such as Kelley Blue Book, Edmunds, or J.D. Power.
Enter the car's year, make, model, mileage, features, and condition. Use your ZIP code to get a value for your area.
Then ask for written offers from a few buyers, such as local dealers or online car buyers. A value guide gives you an estimate; an offer tells you what a buyer is willing to pay.
Compare different sale prices
You may see more than one value for your car.
A dealer offer is usually lower, but selling to a dealer may be quicker.
You might get more by selling directly to another person. That takes more time and work, especially if you still have a loan on the car.
Use the offers you receive to see what you could get now. Use the private-sale estimate to see what you might get if you sell the car yourself.
Compare the value with the payoff
Subtract the payoff amount from what you could sell the car for.
If you could sell the car for more than the payoff, you have equity. You may be able to pay off the loan and keep the money left over.
If the payoff is higher, you owe more than the car is worth. This is sometimes called being upside down. For example, if you owe $14,000 and the car is worth $11,000, the difference is $3,000.
That difference helps you understand how much money you would need to sell the car. It also gives you a starting point for thinking about your other options. If the car is taken and sold, the amount you may still owe will depend on its actual sale price and any allowed costs.
Understand what happens when you return the car
You may still owe money
After you return the car, your lender will usually sell it.
The sale price may be less than you could get by selling the car yourself.
Your lender may also add costs allowed by your loan agreement and state law, such as costs to prepare and sell the car.
If the sale does not cover what you owe and those costs, you may have to pay the difference. This is called a deficiency balance.
What returning the car may save you
Bringing the car to your lender may help you avoid some costs and the stress of having it taken without warning:
- You may avoid a towing or pickup fee,
- You may avoid charges for finding the car,
- You may avoid some storage charges, and
- You can arrange a time to return the car.
Ask your lender which fees you will still owe, and get the answer in writing.
About your credit
Returning the car voluntarily can still hurt your credit. Your lender may report the surrender, along with any missed payments or unpaid balance.
👉 Learn how debt affects your credit score.
You may want to compare other options before you decide, like negotiating a settlement, or explore bankruptcy. Go back to your debt summary to review those options before making a decision.
Call the creditor to discuss returning the car
Decide what to ask for
Returning the car yourself may save your lender the cost of picking it up. You can ask the lender to:
- Leave out any towing or pickup fee if you bring in the car yourself,
- Reduce or forgive any balance left after the sale,
- Tell you how it will report the account to the credit bureaus,
- Send you a written breakdown after the sale showing the sale price, costs, and balance left, and
- Estimate how much you might still owe after the sale.
The lender may not agree to forgive the remaining balance, but you can still ask. They may offer you a discount or a payment plan.
Ask for someone who can approve the terms
If the first person you reach cannot make that decision, ask for a supervisor or someone who handles voluntary returns.
Write down their name and direct phone number, if they have one.
Start the conversation
You can say:
Hi, my name is [your name], and my account number is [account number]. I cannot keep up with my car payments. I may be interested in returning the car to you. Before I do, I want to know what fees you will charge and what I might owe after you sell it. Can we discuss the terms?
Put your request in writing
After the call, send an email or letter so you have a record of what you asked for.
You can write:
My name is [your name], and my account number is [account number]. I am considering returning the car voluntarily. Before I do, please send me the terms in writing.
If I bring the car to you myself, will you charge any towing, pickup, or recovery fees?
Please tell me how the car will be sold. After the sale, please send me a breakdown showing the sale price, each cost, and any balance left.
Please estimate what I might still owe after the sale. Will you [reduce that amount to $[amount] / forgive it in full]?
Please reply in writing. If we agree on the terms, I would like a written agreement, even if it's just an email from you confirming the deal.
If the lender says no
Ask whether a supervisor can review your request. If the answer is still no, decide whether to return the car without those terms or look at your other options on your debt summary page.
Get your agreement in writing
If your creditor offers to lower your payment, take the car back, pause your payments, or hold off on taking the car, get it in writing before you send any money or return the car.
This is the single most important thing you can do to protect yourself in a negotiation. Without it, the creditor can take the car while you think you have a deal.
👉 Learn about your protections from car repossession.
Ask for it on the call
Before you hang up, say this:
Thank you. Can you email me this agreement in writing before I make the first payment? I want to make sure we both have the same terms.
Write down the name of the person you spoke with, the date, and the time.
What the writing has to say
The email or letter should state:
- Your account number,
- The new payment amount and the date each payment is due,
- How long the arrangement lasts,
- What happens to the payments you are skipping, whether they move to the end or come due later,
- Whether interest keeps building during the arrangement,
- That the creditor will not repossess the vehicle while you keep up your end, and
- How the account will be reported to the credit bureaus.
If they will not put it in writing
Take that seriously. A creditor that will not confirm a deal in writing may not honor it.
Then pay on time
Once you have the agreement, treat those dates as hard deadlines. If you can, pay by a method that leaves a record, like a bank transfer or a check. Do not pay in cash.
Set a reminder a few days before each due date so a missed payment does not undo the deal.
Next steps after you return the car
Returning the car may not end the loan. If the car sells for less than you owe, your lender may send you a bill for the difference.
Check the bill before you pay it. You can ask how the amount was calculated and raise questions about charges you do not understand.
Watch for mail about the car and the loan
- A notice about how or when the car will be sold,
- A statement showing the sale price, costs, and balance left,
- A bill for any remaining balance,
- Letters from a debt collector, and
- Court papers if someone sues to collect the debt.
Open these letters as soon as they arrive. Some have deadlines, especially court papers.
Ask how the balance was calculated
Ask your lender in writing for a full breakdown of the amount it says you owe.
The breakdown should show the sale price, each cost charged, and the balance left.
Ask about any charge you do not understand. If you brought the car in yourself, question any towing or pickup fee.
👉 See what happens when the car is sold and what you can do afterward.
Compare the bill with your agreement
Check the bill against the written terms you received before returning the car.
If the lender agreed to reduce or forgive a charge or balance, send a copy of that agreement and ask the lender to correct the bill.
Decide how to handle any balance left
You may be able to ask for a lower payoff amount or a payment plan. Get any new agreement in writing before you pay.
Go back to your Dashboard and add "Negotiate a settlement" as an active option.
If you get court papers, respond by the deadline shown. You can also archive this debt and add a new one with the updated information from your Dashboard.
Check your credit report in about 60 days
See how the account appears on your credit report. If something is wrong, you can dispute it.
👉 Learn how to fix wrong information on your credit report.
🗂️ Keep your records together: Save the written terms, receipt for returning the car, photos, sale notice, and balance breakdown. You may need them if you question a charge later.