Negotiate a payment plan
Prefer to read about this option first? Show the option.
Overview
If a debt collector wants a retail finance debt paid and you can't pay it all at once, you may be able to set up a monthly payment plan you can afford. This works whether you still have the item and owe the rest of the loan, or it was taken back and sold and you owe the deficiency.
A plan gives you time, not a discount. Debt collectors — especially debt buyers — often settle for far less than the full amount, so if you can put together even a small lump sum, it's worth trying to settle first.
Before you agree to a plan, make the collector prove the debt is really yours and check the balance. If your item was repossessed, check whether that was handled correctly too.
Pros
- No large upfront payment: You pay in smaller monthly amounts instead of all at once.
- Avoids a lawsuit: A plan now can keep the collector from suing you.
- Buys time to check the debt: Asking for proof and questioning the balance before you agree protects you from paying something you don't owe.
- Problems are leverage: If they can't prove the debt, or the repossession wasn't handled right, you can ask for a smaller plan — or to have it dropped.
Cons
- Time, not a discount: A plan spreads out what you owe, and interest may keep adding up. A lump sum settlement may cost less if you can manage one.
- Protect yourself on the phone: Don't share your bank or job details, and don't admit you owe the debt — that can restart the clock on how long they have to sue.
- Missing payments has consequences: If you fall behind on the plan, the collector can still sue you for what's left.
How do I do this?
⏳ Ask for proof of the debt (30 day deadline)
Before negotiating a settlement, make sure the debt is real and not a mistake or scam.
Use this Debt Collector Letter Easy Form to request more details.
This form lets you:
- ask for proof of the debt,
- dispute the debt,
- tell the debt collector to stop or limit contacting you, and
- tell the debt collector that you're collection proof.
⚡Act quickly. Send the letter within 30 days after you get the debt collector's validation notice. Check the notice for the exact date. If you ask in writing by then, the debt collector has to give you certain information before it keeps collecting.
To further verify that the debt collector is legitimate, you can:
- Call the original creditor and ask if your debt has been sold or sent to collections, and
- Check your credit report to see if the debt collector appears on your report.
🗂️ Keep records: Keep any papers the debt collector gives you with your bills and other papers.
Make sure the balance is right
Which situation are you in?
How you check the balance depends on what has happened with your item:
- You still have the item, and the creditor just wants the rest of the loan paid. The balance is what's left on your contract, plus any late fees, and
- The item was already taken back and resold. The leftover balance — what you owed, minus what the sale brought in, plus the creditor's costs — is called a deficiency. Once the item is sold it's gone, so this is now just a money debt.
Get the balance in writing
Before you offer to settle, ask the creditor for a written breakdown of what you owe. You have the right to see what makes up the balance — the original amount, the payments you've made, and any fees or interest. Get it in writing so you have a record.
Check for common errors
- Payments not credited: money you already paid that isn't subtracted from the balance,
- Duplicate or extra charges that don't make sense,
- Interest that seems too high: a rate over 36% APR could be a violation of Illinois law, and
- Charges that aren't yours, from mixed-up accounts or identity theft.
💡 If your item was repossessed: The creditor can only collect a deficiency if they handled the repossession and sale correctly — like sending you the right notices and selling the item in a reasonable way. If they didn't, the deficiency may be reduced or even canceled, so it's worth checking before you agree to pay. Learn how to check if a repossession or deficiency was handled correctly.
Find your negotiating power
If the debt collector can't show you owe the debt or broke the rules, you can use this as a way to negotiate a better settlement and a fairer outcome.
We can help you find your negotiating power.
Understand how debt buyers and debt collection agencies work
Debt buyers purchase debts for big discounts. One study found that a debt buyer paid less than 10 cents for every dollar of debt. This means that even if you can afford to pay a small percentage of the debt, even 20%, it may be worth trying to negotiate a lump sum settlement.
Debt collection agencies are hired to collect on debt. They are usually paid a commission, which means they make money when they collect on the debt, even if it's not for the full amount. They may be open to negotiating a discount to make sure they get paid.
Do they have enough information to prove the debt?
To take money from you, a debt collector usually has to take you to court and get a judgment. If the debt is secured by an item you bought, the debt collector may also be able to take the item back, but only if it follows strict rules.
The debt collector must prove:
- You owe the debt,
- The debt buyer owns the debt (or the debt collection agency was assigned the debt),
- The amount is correct, and
- The debt isn't too old for the debt collector to bring a lawsuit.
If the debt collector can't prove these, then you can use this to your advantage negotiating with the debt collector.
Are they trying to collect the right amount?
If you don't already have a breakdown of the debt, ask the creditor's lawyer for one. You have the right to see what makes up the balance, including the original amount and any added fees or interest. Get it in writing so you have a record.
Check for common errors:
- Payments not credited: Money you already paid that isn't subtracted from the balance or was applied to the wrong account.
- Duplicate charges: The same fee or item billed more than once.
- Extra charges that don't make sense.
- High interest rates: If the interest rate is over 36% APR this could be a violation of the Illinois Predatory Loan Prevention Act.
- Charges that aren't yours: If someone else charged the account without your permission, the company mixed up accounts, or identity theft.
- For utilities, charges made after you moved out or deposits that weren't credited to your account.
- Debts that were already settled or discharged through bankruptcy.
If the debt collector is trying to collect the wrong amount, they may be in violation of the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act.
Did the debt collector break the law?
Debt collectors are also required to follow the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. If the debt collector broke the law, you can use this to your advantage to negotiate a better settlement.
Under this law, debt collectors:
- Can’t harass or threaten you,
- Must tell the truth about the amount you owe,
- Can’t call you before 8 AM or after 9 PM, and
- Must stop contacting you if you ask in writing.
Your results:
Next steps
In the next steps, we'll walk you through how to consider your negotiation powers when deciding on your settlement plan.
If the debt collector broke the law, you may want to talk with a lawyer to better understand your options.
💡 Did you know? If you have a claim against a debt collector, a consumer lawyer may take your case on a contingency basis. That means that you don't pay anything, unless you win or settle your claims against the debt collector.
See if you're protected from collections
The only way a creditor can force you to pay the debt is by suing you and getting a judgment.
Even if they win a judgment, you may be protected if:
- Your take-home wages are less than $675 per week,
- You have $4,000 or less in the bank (by using your $4,000 wildcard protection),
- If you own a home, your equity is less than:
- $50,000 if you own by yourself or
- $100,000 if you own with someone else who lives there,
- If you own a car, your equity is less than $3,600 (plus what you want to apply from your $4,000 wildcard), and
- You don’t own valuable items like jewelry, antiques, art, or electronics that are worth more than $5,000.
If you don’t have property a creditor can take, you are collection proof. Creditors can still sue, but they may decide not to pursue collection if they know they can’t recover anything.
👉 Learn more about what is protected from collections.
🛠️ If you would like a detailed review of your property that may be subject to collections, you can use our collection-proof tool.
How the wildcard protection works
You can use a wildcard to protect $4,000 of any personal property from collections. You can use it to protect money in your bank account, equity in your car, or personal property in your home.
For example:
- If a creditor tries to garnish your bank account with $1,500 in it, you could use $1,500 of your wildcard to protect your bank account; and
- If the creditor tries to force the sale of your car, which is unlikely, you could apply the remaining amount of your wildcard to your car. This would increase the amount of equity you can protect in your car from $3,600 to $6,100.
Next steps if you're collection proof
If you haven't been sued yet
If you are collection proof and do not think your financial situation will change, you may consider telling the creditor that you're collection proof. They may decide to stop spending money trying to collect the debt if they know they won't be able to get any money from you, even with a judgment.
If you've been sued
If you are collection proof and do not think your financial situation will change, you may consider:
- Ignoring the lawsuit: Even if the creditor gets a judgment, they won't be able to collect anything from you. It does not make sense to pay the creditor anything if they won’t ever be able to legally force you to pay. Note that you can't ignore orders of the court to appear, like a citation to discover assets that is directed to you.
- Telling the creditor that you're collection proof: If they know they can't collect anything from you, they may stop the lawsuit or not try to collect on the judgment.
👉 Learn how a judgment can impact your ability to get housing or employment.
⚠️ Be careful if your situation may change. You may be collection proof right now, but that could change in the future. Judgments can last a long time in Illinois - see how long it might last. That means a creditor could wait until you have income or assets they can take.
Example: A recent high school graduate might be collection proof while in college or trade school. But once they start working, they may no longer be protected.
Know what you can afford
What can you afford?
Decide how much you can really pay each month without missing rent, food, or other basics. Use a debt repayment calculator to help figure out a monthly payment you can afford.
⚠️ This is your limit. Don't agree to a payment plan that goes beyond what you can safely pay each month.
Can you afford a lump sum payment?
If you can afford to pay part of the debt all at once, even 30%-50%, you may want to offer to a lump sum settlement first before negotiating a payment plan.
Use your negotiating power
You may be able to negotiate a discount on the debt—or ask them to stop collecting the debt—if you have strong reasons, like:
- You are collection proof,
- Your debt is too old to bring a lawsuit,
- The debt collector can't prove it owns the debt,
- The debt collector broke the law,
- You're thinking about filing for bankruptcy.
Don't worry if the debt collector says no to your offer. You can always keep negotiating or call back later.
Make your offer
Prepare
Before you call, write down your account number, your opening offer (the monthly amount and number of payments), and the most you can afford each month.
Be ready to take notes. Write down the name of the person you talk to, the name of the original creditor, the details of any offer, and any deadlines.
⚠️ Important:
- Don't give the collector information about your bank accounts or your job, and
- Don't admit you owe the debt or promise to pay it — that can restart the clock on how long they have to sue.
Start the conversation
Take a deep breath. It's okay to feel nervous, but taking action helps. Call the collector — their number is on any letter they sent you.
You can say:
Hi, my name is [your name] and I'm calling about a debt you're trying to collect. I'm going through a hard time and can't pay the full balance. I'd like to set up a monthly payment plan I can afford. Can we work something out?
Tell them about your negotiating power
The collector may be more willing to work with you if you explain why a plan makes sense.
If your item is still yours
You can say:
I still have the item and want to keep it. I'd like a plan I can afford to pay off the balance — and I want it in writing that once it's paid off, the account is closed and the item is mine free and clear.
If there may be a problem with the repossession or sale
You can say:
I don't think this deficiency was handled correctly under Illinois law. I'd like a smaller plan that reflects that — or to have it dropped.
If you're dealing with a debt buyer
You can say:
I understand your company likely bought this debt for much less than the full amount. I'd like to set up a plan for a fair amount based on what you paid.
If you're collection proof
You can say:
I want to be honest with you — my only income is protected by law and I don't have assets you can take. Even with a judgment, you wouldn't be able to collect from me. I'm still willing to set up something reasonable, but I can't agree to anything I can't afford.
If the debt is too old
You can say:
It's been years since my last payment, so I think this debt may be too old for you to sue over. I'll only agree to something that's fair.
If the collector may not be able to prove its case
You can say:
I've looked at what you sent, and I'm not sure you have all the proof you'd need to win in court. Rather than go through a legal fight, I'm willing to set up a reasonable plan now.
Ask questions and take notes
Ask the collector:
- What's the lowest monthly payment you can accept,
- Will you stop late fees,
- Will you stop charging interest — and if not, what's the lowest rate you can offer, and
- How will the plan be reported on my credit report?
Don't agree to pay more than you can afford each month
If the amount is too high, you can say:
I want to pay, but that amount is too much for me right now. Is there a way to lower the payment or give me more time?
💡 Debt collectors tend to keep calling. You're not required to take their calls, and you can use the Debt Collector Letter Easy Form to tell them to stop. That won't make the debt go away, but it may lower your stress while you work things out.
If you agree, get it in writing
Ask for the plan in writing before your first payment.
You can say:
Can you send me the agreement in writing? I want to make sure I understand it before I start paying.
⚠️ Important: Do not make your first payment until you have the agreement in writing.
Review the written agreement
When you receive the settlement agreement, read it carefully to make sure it matches what you agreed to.
Check that it clearly states:
- Your monthly payment amount
- The number of payments you will make
- The total amount you will pay
- When each payment is due
- Whether interest will be charged
- What happens if you miss or are late on a payment
- What will happen with your court case (if there is one)
- How the debt will be reported to credit reporting agencies (if applicable)
Make sure the agreement doesn’t include anything you didn’t agree to, like extra fees or new rules.
If there is a problem
Do not sign the agreement yet. Contact the creditor and ask them to fix the issue and send you a corrected agreement in writing.
If the agreement looks good
Sign and return the agreement and make your payments on time. Follow the payment instructions carefully:
- Include your account or reference number with each payment
- Pay by check or electronic transfer so you have a record (do not pay with cash)
- Consider setting reminders so you don’t miss a payment
Keep records
Keep a copy of the agreement and proof of each payment for your records.
⚠️ Important: If something doesn’t look right or you have questions, call the creditor and ask them to fix it before you sign and pay.
Set calendar reminders to make your monthly payments
Set up reminders on your phone or calendar to send your monthly payments. When you pay, keep proof, like a receipt or screenshot. This helps protect you if there's ever a mistake.
If you know the money will be in your account each month, consider setting up autopay.
If you can't pay on time one month, call right away. If something happens and you can't pay one month, call the creditor before you miss the payment.
You can say:
"I’m having trouble this month and might miss my payment. Can we work something out or move the payment to next month?"
💡 Get it in writing: Keep a record of who you spoke with, the date, and what was said. Always ask the creditor to send you a written copy of any agreement so you have proof of the terms.
Mark your calendar to check your credit report
Find the date of your last payment under the settlement.
Set a calendar reminder for 60 days after your last payment to check your credit report.
If something doesn’t look right or you have questions, call your creditor and ask them to fix it. You can also send a letter to the credit reporting agencies to fix it.