Fight the debt over a bad purchase

Get information tailored to your debt

This option is for people who financed a defective item through a store. If your situation is different, some steps may not apply, or a different option may work better for you.

Let us guide you to the available options for you.

Begin your journey
Prefer to read about this option first? Show the option.

Overview

When you buy something like furniture, an appliance, or electronics and finance it through the seller, the loan is often handled by a separate finance company. Normally a finance company would say, "Your complaint is with the store, not us — keep paying." 

But most of these contracts include a special notice called the FTC Holder Rule notice. It lets you raise the seller's problems against the finance company that holds your loan. So if the item was defective, never delivered, or the seller lied about it, you can use that against whoever is collecting — not just the store. 

You can use the Holder Rule as a defense to lower or even cancel what you still owe. If you want money back, the most you can usually get back is what you've already paid on the contract.

Pros

  • Holds the finance company responsible: You can raise the seller's misconduct against the company collecting your loan, instead of being told it's "not their problem."
  • Can lower or cancel what you owe: Used as a defense, a valid Holder Rule claim can reduce the balance — or wipe it out — depending on how serious the seller's problem was.
  • Works in or out of court: You can raise it as a defense if you're sued, or use it as leverage to push for a better deal before a lawsuit starts.

Cons

  • You have to prove the seller's problem: You'll need to show the item was defective or the seller broke a promise, with records like photos, repair attempts, or written communications.
  • Limited money back: If you're asking for a refund rather than just reducing the debt, the most you can usually recover is what you've already paid on the contract.
  • The notice has to be there: The Holder Rule applies because of language in your contract. You'll need to check that your contract includes it.

How do I do this?

Keep making your monthly payments on time

Consult a consumer lawyer before stopping payments based on the Holder Rule.  

If your claim is unsuccessful, the lender may send your debt to collections, report your late payments to the credit reporting agencies, and even bring a lawsuit for the debt.  

👉 Learn how to find a consumer lawyer.  

Check your contract for Holder Rule notice

The Holder Rule works because of a notice that's supposed to be printed in your contract. It usually appears in capital letters and says that anyone who holds the contract is subject to all claims and defenses you could raise against the seller. 

Look for a paragraph that starts with the words 

NOTICE: ANY HOLDER OF THIS CONSUMER CREDIT CONTRACT IS SUBJECT TO ALL CLAIMS AND DEFENSES WHICH THE DEBTOR COULD ASSERT AGAINST THE SELLER . . .

⚠️ If your contract doesn't include this notice but should have, that may be a separate violation by the seller. Learn how to find a consumer lawyer. 

Identify what went wrong with the purchase

The Holder Rule lets you raise the kinds of complaints you'd have against the store, including: 

  • The item was defective or broke quickly, 
  • The item was never delivered,
  • The item wasn't what was promised, or
  •  The seller misled you about the price or terms.  

Write down specifically what went wrong and when. 

Contact the seller first

It's best to try to contact the company that sold you the product first before raising it with the retail finance company. For some claims, you need to contact the seller to preserve the claim. Plus, in many situations, the seller may be able to more easily fix the problem.

Take notes and keep documents. If the seller does not fix your problem, this builds on the documents you have to force the retail finance company to take action.  

Gather your documents

You'll need evidence the problem was real. Helpful records include:

  • photos or video of the defect, 
  • receipts and the contract itself, 
  • repair or service requests, and 
  • any texts, emails, or letters with the seller about the problem.

💪 The stronger and better-documented the seller's problem, the stronger your Holder Rule claim.

Raise the issue with your finance company

Raise the issue to your retail finance company directly You can call first if you want, but always follow up with a demand in writing. A written demand creates a record, forces them to take the problem seriously, and is the first step toward getting your balance lowered or canceled.

Decide how you want to raise the issue

The Holder Rule can work two ways. 

  • As a defense, you use it to lower or cancel what you still owe. 
  • As a claim for money back, you can ask to recover what you've already paid, but usually no more than that.

What to include in your written demand

Make sure to include the following information in your written demand to let the retail finance company identify the debt and your problem: 

  • Your account number and the date of purchase
  • What you bought and what went wrong (the item was defective, never delivered, or not what the seller promised)
  • That you already tried to resolve it with the seller, and what happened
  • That your contract contains the Holder Rule notice, so they're responsible for the seller's problem
  • Exactly what you want them to do (cancel the balance, lower it, or stop collection)

Example of what you could say 

Here is an example of what you could say in a written demand: 

I'm writing about account [number] for [item] purchased on [date]. The item was [defective / never delivered / not as promised]. I contacted the seller on [date] and [what happened]. My contract includes the FTC Holder Rule notice, which makes your company subject to the same claims and defenses I could raise against the seller. Because of this problem, I am asking you to [cancel the remaining balance / reduce it to $___ / stop collection on this account]. Please respond in writing within 30 days.

📂 Keep a copy of the demand and proof you sent it (email, or certified mail receipt if by letter).

Be ready if the retail finance company calls you

The retail finance company or a debt collector may call you. You can use that call to state your position clearly — but keep it short, stick to the facts, and don't agree to pay or make promises on the spot.

If they call, you can say:  

I've sent a written complaint about this account. The item was [defective / not as promised], and my contract has the Holder Rule notice, so your company is responsible for the seller's problem. I'm not able to discuss payment until this is resolved. Please put any response in writing.

⚠️ Don't agree to a payment plan or a settlement on the call before your Holder Rule claim is resolved — it can weaken your position. Get any offer in writing first.

Know what to expect

The finance company may: 

  • agree to fix the balance, 
  • offer a partial reduction, or 
  • push back and keep collecting. 

If the retail finance company cooperates

If they cooperate, get the agreement in writing before you do anything else. 

If the retail finance company does not cooperate

If they refuse, your Holder Rule claim doesn't go away — you can still raise it later as a defense if they sue you, and a stronger, well-documented claim gives you leverage to negotiate.

You can: