Challenge service
Prefer to read about this option first? Show the option.
Overview
If you're sued for a debt, the creditor must follow the rules for delivering your court papers. If you didn’t get the papers (or didn’t get them the right way) and the court entered a default judgment, you can ask the court to cancel the judgment against you. This is an advanced option, and it is difficult to win this kind of motion.
Pros
- Protect your legal rights: You have the right to be told if someone sues you. If you were not served the right way, the judgment might not be valid.
- Might cancel judgment: If your service was not done properly, the court could cancel the judgment against you.
- Might stop collections: If the court cancels the judgment, then the creditor must stop garnishments and remove liens.
Cons
- Very high bar: You will likely need to present “clear and satisfactory” proof that you weren't served.
- It might not change the outcome: Even if the service was done wrong, the creditor can still continue with the lawsuit.
- The court may not agree with you: Even if you think service was improper, the court may not agree with you.
- Extra paperwork and stress: Filing paperwork and going to court takes time and can be stressful.
How do I do this?
Know the service rules
In Illinois, legal papers must be:
- Handed to you directly,
- Left with someone who lives with you and is at least 13 years old, or
- Mailed to you—but usually only if you agreed to that.
Get your court papers if you don't have them
If you did not receive court papers for your case, you need to request them from the court. Call the clerk in the court where you were sued and ask how to get the documents.
Here is what you can say:
I believe there is a court case filed against me, but I don't think I was properly served with the papers. I'd like to get copies of the court papers for my case.
The clerk will ask for your name to look up the case. If the clerk finds the case, ask what has been filed in the case:
Could you please tell me the case number and what papers have been filed in my case?
Ask for:
- The summons;
- The complaint;
- The proof of service, and
- The judgment, if one has been entered in the case.
Make sure you understand how to get the court documents. The clerk may print them out for you on paper or direct you to a website where you can look up the case.
How can I get copies of the court documents and how much will it cost?
Review the court documents carefully
Summons
The summons is the paper that tells you about the lawsuit. It says when and where you need to respond.
🔍 Check carefully: Make sure your name, addresses, and the date are correct. Note any mistakes. This could help your case.
Proof of service
The proof of service is a paper filed by someone that says how, when, and where you were served. Read this carefully. If something seems off, take notes.
📝 Write down: where you were, who gave you the papers, and what happened. These details can help your case.
Decide how to use improper service in your case
If the creditor did not serve you the right way, you can possibly use this to cancel the default judgment or as part of settlement negotiations.
Note: A motion telling the court you weren't served properly needs to be filed before you file any other motion or pleading in the case.
Ask the court to "quash service" and cancel the judgment
You can file a Motion to Quash and Vacate the Judgment and tell the judge that you weren't properly notified about the lawsuit. If the judge agrees, the creditor would have to start all over and try to serve you correctly. This can give you more time to prepare or even stop the case altogether.
Many courts will require you to have some kind of proof to show you weren't served the right way. For example, if your Proof of Service says you were served at a time when you were at work, you could use your time card to prove this is not correct. You can also get sworn statements from people who know you were somewhere else.
Use improper service as leverage in settlement
Even if a judgment has been entered against you, it's not too late to negotiate a settlement. You can talk to the creditor's lawyer and use improper service as leverage to negotiate a better settlement.
Do both
You can file the motion and also talk to the creditor. Doing both can put more pressure on them to settle the judgment.
File a Motion to Quash Service and Vacate Default Judgment (Optional)
If you haven't been properly served, you can file a Motion to Quash Service and Vacate Default Judgment.
- This legal action can pressure the creditor to settle the debt for a lesser amount or drop the case altogether.
- Even if the judgment is canceled, the creditor may try to serve you again.
File a Motion to Vacate Default Judgment
To do this, return to your Summary page and choose the option to ask the court to undo the judgment (Section 2-1401 Petition). That will walk you through filing a petition.
Negotiate a settlement (Optional)
Use improper service as leverage in negotiating a settlement
Creditors want to recover money as efficiently as possible. If they realize you weren’t served properly, they may be more willing to settle the judgment to avoid delays and costs.
Understand what you can afford
Before negotiating, review your finances. Only agree to a settlement you can realistically afford without missing rent, food, or other essentials.
Figure out what type of settlement works best for your situation.
Lump Sum Settlement
A lump sum settlement is a one-time payment usually for less than the full amount of the debt. Some creditors accept 50%–75%, or even less if service was improper.
Payment Plan
A payment plan allows you to pay smaller monthly amounts over time.
After a judgment is entered, you are allowed to ask the court for a payment plan that can last up to 36 months if the judgment is under $10,000. If service was done incorrectly, you may be able to negotiate a discount on the amount you owe.
💡 Start small. When negotiating any type of settlement, start small. This gives you room to negotiate without going beyond what you can afford. You can always offer more later.
Start the conversation
Take a deep breath. It's okay to feel nervous, but taking action helps.
Call the creditor's lawyer. Their number should be listed on your court papers. Check page 2 of the Summons.
Ask for the case to be dismissed
Start by asking for the case to be dismissed.
Here is an example of what you can say:
Hello, my name is [Your Full Name]. I’m calling about the case your office filed against me for [Debt Collector or Creditor Name]. The case number is [Case Number], filed in [County] Circuit Court.
I recently learned about this case, but I was never properly served with the court papers. I reviewed the Illinois rules for service, and it looks like I should have been served in person or had the papers given to someone who lives at my home. That did not happen.
Because of this, I may file a motion to quash service. But I’d rather try to work this out without going back and forth in court. Would your client be willing to dismiss the case?
Make an opening offer
If they won't agree to dismiss your case, you can make an opening settlement offer.
Hello, my name is [Your Full Name]. I’m calling about the case your office filed against me for [Debt Collector or Creditor Name]. The case number is [Case Number], filed in [County] Circuit Court.
I recently learned about this case, but I was never properly served with the court papers. I reviewed the Illinois rules for service, and it looks like I should have been served in person or had the papers given to someone who lives at my home. That did not happen.
Because of this, I may file a motion to vacate the default judgment. But I’d rather try to work this out without going back and forth in court.
I’m open to a fair settlement and want to know if your client would be willing to resolve the case for a lower amount, given you didn't properly serve me. I am willing to pay [$ Opening Offer] to fully settle the judgment.
Only agree if you can afford the lump sum or payments
If the amount the creditor offers is too high, say:
I want to pay, but that amount is too much for me right now. Is there a way to lower the payment or give me more time?
🚫 Do not agree to a plan unless you are sure you can afford it.
Negotiate other important details
After you agree on a settlement amount, go over the details and take notes.
- The interest rate (for payment plans),
- That the one-time payment will settle the whole judgment,
- That the creditor will file a Satisfaction and Release of Judgment in your case, and
- How and when the debt will be updated with the credit reporting agencies.
👉 Learn how debts can be updated with the credit reporting agencies after you settle the debt.
💡 Keep in mind: The legal interest rate for consumer debts under $25,000 is 5% in Illinois.
Keep notes
Write down:
- Date and time of the call
- Who you spoke with
- Your offer and their response
- Payment amount and timeline
- Interest rate (if any)
- What happens in court and on your credit report
Having these details will help you review the settlement agreement when you get it in writing.
⚠️ Do not make your settlement payment until you get the written agreement.
Get the settlement in writing
If you reach an agreement with your creditor, ask for the agreement in writing.
Can you please send me the agreement in writing? I want to make sure everything is clear before I make the first payment.
Review the settlement agreement
Before signing, double-check:
- Payment amount and deadline
- Interest rate (for payment plans)
- Case dismissal (no judgment)
- Credit reporting language (paid vs. settled)
- No extra fees or surprise terms
📞 If anything’s unclear, call the lawyer before signing.
Make your payment
- Sign and return the agreement,
- Include your case number with your payment,
- Pay by check or electronic transfer (do not pay in cash), and
- Keep records of all payments and documents.
Follow up
Make sure the creditor kept their end of the bargain.
Court case
After you make your final payment, make sure the creditor's lawyer has filed a Satisfaction and Release of Judgment with the court in your case.
If something’s wrong, call the creditor's lawyer and ask them to fix it.
🧭 Need help finding court documents? Call or text Illinois Court Help at 833-411-1121.
Credit report
After your final payment, check your credit report for free at AnnualCreditReport.com. If something’s wrong, call the lawyer or send a dispute letter to the credit reporting agencies.