Defenses for non-hospital medical debt

Defenses for non-hospital medical debt

1186

Defenses for non-hospital medical debt

Are there errors on the medical bill?

If a collection agency or law firm is trying to collect, the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) and state laws apply. These laws say collectors cannot try to collect debts that are inaccurate, unproven, or too old.

You may have a defense if the bill has errors in it, like: 

  • All or part of your bill was already paid by you, your insurance, or Medicare/Medicaid,
  • You were charged for care you didn't receive,
  • The bill lists more expensive services than what was actually provided,
  • Your bill has out-of-network charges that violate the No Surprises Act, or
  • The collector can’t show records to support the amount charged.

👉 Learn how to check with your insurance company to make sure they paid their fair share.

Are the charges unreasonable?

You may have a defense if the amount they are charging you is much higher than what is normally accepted by Medicare, Medicaid, or other insurers.  

Did you dispute the bill? 

If you disputed the bill, this can be used as a defense under an "account stated" claim because the hospital cannot claim you silently agreed to the charges.

Does the medical debt appear on your credit report?

Starting on January 1, 2025, medical debt may no longer appear on credit reports in Illinois. 

Check your credit report to make sure your medical debt does not show up on your report.  Medical debt should not appear on your credit report if:  

  • Your medical care occurred in Illinois; or
  • Your credit report was purchased or used in Illinois.

If medical debt appears on your credit report, the debt collector may have violated the Fair Credit Reporting Act and the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Businesses Practices Act.  

👉 Learn how to dispute information on your credit report. 

Uncertainty about the future of the Illinois law. There is some uncertainty right now whether federal law could override the Illinois law. In October 2025, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau said that the Fair Credit Reporting Act (a federal law) may not allow states to ban medical debt from credit reports. This alone does not make the Illinois law change. To change Illinois law, the federal government would have to take Illinois to court and a judge would have to decide to overturn the Illinois law.

Other defenses

If the care provider says you owe money because of a contract, you may be able to argue the charges or agreement are not valid.

You may have a defense if:

  • There's no real contract: The provider cannot prove you agreed to the charges, especially if you only signed a vague form saying you were “financially responsible.”
  • You signed under pressure:  Any agreement signed during an emergency or high stress may be considered made under duress.
  • The provider was negligent in telling you how much your insurance would cover.
  • The provider committed malpractice (even if you don't bring a malpractice lawsuit).
  • The provider did not provide a translated version of a contract to a non-English speaker.
 
Last revised by staff
September 29, 2025