Using arbitration to your advantage

Using arbitration to your advantage

906

Using arbitration to your advantage

Some courts use arbitration or mediation to resolve cases before a trial. These options can feel unfamiliar, but in the right situation, you can use arbitration to your advantage. 

Types of arbitration and mediation

Private arbitration

Private arbitration, which is separate from court, usually happens through organizations like the American Arbitration Association (AAA) or JAMS.

Court arbitration

Some Illinois courts use mandatory arbitration when the amount at issue is between $10,000 and $50,000. This may also happen if either side requests a jury trial.

Mandatory arbitration is similar to a trial, but it’s more informal. The case is heard by a neutral third party (an arbitrator or a panel). After listening to both sides, the arbitrator issues a decision.

Either side can reject the decision and ask for a regular trial in court.

Mediation

Some courts may require that you attend mediation. Mediation is a process where a neutral third person, called a mediator, helps both sides in a dispute talk through the issues and try to reach an agreement.

  • The mediator does not make a decision like a judge or arbitrator.
  • They guide the conversation, help each side explain their concerns, and suggest possible solutions.
  • Mediation is usually voluntary and confidential.
  • Any agreement reached is only binding if both sides choose to sign it.

How private arbitration can help you

In small claims consumer debt cases, your costs to arbitrate is capped–you usually pay $250 or less. But the debt collector may have to pay hundreds or even thousands of dollars in arbitration fees.

Because of this, some debt collectors may decide that it’s not worth it to keep going or they may offer to settle the case for less money.

Read your agreement with the debt collector closely to see if you qualify

You may qualify for arbitration if your contract with the debt collector says you can arbitrate disputes. 

If you are dealing with credit card debt, search the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s credit card agreement database to find your agreement. 

Read any part about arbitration closely. If your agreement says you can use private arbitration, then you can file a motion asking the judge to pause your case and order arbitration.

Ask the court to stop your case and let you arbitrate

If your agreement says you can use arbitration, you can file a motion asking the judge to pause the case and order arbitration.

You will need to write a motion that

  • Tells the judge that your agreement gives you the right to demand private arbitration,
  • Tells the judge where this provision is in the agreement,
  • Gives the judge a copy of the contract,
  • Asks the judge to pause or dismiss the court case while private arbitration moves forward, and
  • Asks the judge to order that the creditor is the one that has to start the arbitration because it will be the Claimant in the arbitration case. The creditor should also pay the fee to start the arbitration.

Use the Motion Easy Form to draft your motion, then e-file it with the court.

Last revised by staff
July 29, 2025