If a friend or relative is asking to be paid back, the first question is whether there was ever a real agreement to repay. You have to pay back a loan. You do not have to pay back a gift.
Signs it was a loan
These are signs that the money was a loan:
- You agreed to pay the money back,
- There was a due date or a schedule,
- They charged interest,
- You already made some payments, or
- You texted, emailed, or wrote something about paying it back.
Signs it was a gift
These are sign that the money was a gift:
- No one talked about paying it back,
- There was no due date and no interest, and
- It was given for a birthday, a holiday, or to help you out.
💡 Good to know: Money a parent gives an adult child is usually presumed to be a gift in Illinois, not a loan. This means the person claiming it is a loan would need to give the court clear and convincing evidence that it was a loan before a court would enter a judgment.
If you disagree about whether it was a gift or a loan
Gather anything that shows what was really agreed:
- Text messages, emails, or app memos (like a Venmo or Cash App note),
- Bank records showing the money moving, and
- Notes about what was said, and who else was there.
🗂️ Keep records: Save these before you respond. If this ever goes to court, the messages and payment records are what the judge will look at.