Watch out for alternative energy suppliers

Watch out for alternative energy suppliers

1896

Watch out for alternative energy suppliers

If a salesperson at your door, a caller, or a mailer is promising to lower your electric or gas bill by switching to a different supplier, it pays to slow down. In Illinois, these companies are called alternative energy suppliers, and while switching is legal, it often costs people more than staying with their regular utility. 

Here is how they work and what to watch for.

What is an alternative energy supplier?

Your electric or gas bill has three parts:

  • Supply includes the charges for the actual electricity you use. 
  • Transmission Service is the charge for getting energy from the generation source to the local distribution system.
  • Distribution Service includes the charges for delivering the energy to your home. 

Illinois law lets you buy the supply part from a company other than your utility. 

  • For electricity, these companies are called alternative retail electric suppliers, or ARES. 
  • For natural gas, they are called alternative gas suppliers, or AGS.

No matter who supplies your energy, your regulated utility — like ComEd, Ameren, Nicor, or Peoples Gas — still delivers it, reads your meter, and handles outages and safety. Switching suppliers does not change who fixes a downed line or a gas leak.

Why switching often costs more, not less

The offers can sound like a clear win, but the data tell a different story. The National Consumer Law Center found that Illinois households buying supplies from alternative retail electric suppliers overpaid by $389 million in one year compared to what they would have paid their regulated utility.

Here is how a good-sounding deal turns expensive:

  • A low "teaser" rate for the first month or two, that jumps once the introductory period ends,
  • A variable rate that can change every month without warning, sometimes to more than double your utility's price, and
  • Contracts that renew automatically, so you stay locked in unless you cancel.

⚠️ Be careful: A rate that beats your utility today can climb far above it next month. Ask whether the price is fixed or variable, exactly how long any introductory rate lasts, and what the rate becomes after that.

Check the price of regulated energy before you sign a contract

Before signing up with an ARES, make sure you know the price your regulated electric company is charging.  

PlugIn Illinois gives you the regulated supply price to compare against an alternative supplier.  

"Green" offers can be overpriced too

Some suppliers advertise renewable or "green" energy. These plans are often marked up in the same way — you may pay a premium for renewable energy credits that do little to add clean power. A green label does not mean the price is a good deal. Compare the actual price per kilowatt-hour, not the marketing.

Switching will not get you out of a past due bill

Switching suppliers does not erase what you owe, and it will not stop a shut-off on its own. If you are struggling to pay, focus on your utility and the assistance programs that exist for that. 

Sales tactics to watch for

Watch for these signs:

  • A salesperson who quotes a rate but glosses over that it is only an introductory price,
  • Pressure to "verify your account" by reading your account number off your bill,
  • Claims to be from your utility, or working "with" it, when they are a separate company, and
  • Finding your supplier changed on your bill when you never agreed to switch.
  • Offering you money up front. You may end up paying much more in energy costs than the $75 Visa check card they offer for signing up.  

🗂️ Keep records: Save any contract, mailer, or written summary, and write down the date, company name, and rate a salesperson quotes you. If the bill does not match what you were promised, those notes matter.

Getting out of a contract

If you switch to an alternative energy supplier and regret it:

  • You can cancel within 10 days of the date your utility processes the switch. The utility sends you a written notice of the enrollment and the new supplier's name, and
  • You can return to your utility for supply at any time — the utility will not charge a fee to take you back, though you may have to stay with the utility for at least 12 months afterward.

The supplier's own contract may still charge an early termination fee if you leave before the term ends, so read the contract before you sign and again before you cancel.

How to protect yourself

  • Compare the full price per kilowatt-hour or therm against your utility's price to compare, not just the first-month rate,
  • Ask whether the rate is fixed or variable, how long the contract runs, and what fees apply if you leave, using the state's list of questions to ask a supplier, and
  • Do not feel rushed — a real offer will still be there tomorrow.

If you think a supplier misled you

If you were switched without permission, charged a rate you never agreed to, or misled by a salesperson, you can file a complaint. 

👉 File a complaint with the Illinois Commerce Commission. The ICC regulates energy suppliers, 

👉 File a complaint with the Illinois Attorney General's Consumer Protection Division. 

👉 Review your rights and cancellation options for alternative energy suppliers from Plug In Illinois.

Last revised by staff
July 10, 2026