Evidence for common defenses

Evidence for common defenses

1156

Evidence for common defenses

Here are some examples of documents that could support your defenses in a case:

The debt isn't mine

  • Government-issued ID (to show name or address mismatch)
  • Proof of where you lived when the account was opened or used
  • Statements from your real accounts showing no connection to the debt at issue
  • Letters or emails where you disputed the debt

The amount is wrong

  • Original credit card or loan statements
  • Final billing statement or charge-off letter
  • Letters or emails from the original creditor about the balance
  • Payment records (bank statements, canceled checks, or receipts)
  • Any letters disputing the amount

The debt is too old

  • Bank statements or billing records showing the last payment date
  • Letters or emails from the creditor confirming your last payment or acknowledgement
  • Credit reports with last activity date
  • A copy of the Illinois statute of limitations for your type of debt

The debt buyer doesn't own the debt

  • Letters from the original creditor (for example, saying the account was closed, charged off, or sold)
  • Documents from the debt buyer that are incomplete, inconsistent, or missing the assignment of your specific account
  • Court documents (complaint or affidavit) that don't include a clear "chain or title" showing how your account was bought and sold
  • Copies of your debt validation requests that weren't answered or had poor responses
Last revised by staff
September 28, 2025